Activism out of control

Maybe they’ve been protecting another kind of species, like a queen bee?

TENSIONS between extreme animal rights activists and frustrated piggery owners near Young in south-eastern NSW are fast escalating towards an ugly head-on collision.

Whether that inevitable crash takes place in a court room or a back paddock remains to be seen.

The public battle zone intensified this week when Animal Liberation NSW and ACT released inflammatory video footage obtained from repeated covert operations targeted at one Young property earlier this year.

The vision shows some practices considered unacceptable, which the owner admits to.

But the video largely aims to prosecute another trial by media conviction against hard working farmers, in the absence of expert commentary and facts.

“It’s probably taken them seven months to find the bad stuff and edit the video down to this,” one source said this week.

“And of course they haven’t shown any of the good things like people caring for sick piglets.”

As one observer put it, the animal rights’ group’s accompanying media statement contained “very personal and targeted language” directed at piggery owner Edwina Beveridge.

“It just keeps getting uglier,” another source said.

Among the statement’s inflammatory claims, it said video footage taken by hand-held and hidden cameras appeared to show evidence of forceful artificial insemination in a “rape shed”.

Typically, the activists failed to explain why, if they felt the “rape shed” and vision was so shocking and severe, they took so long to take real action or release these images publicly.

Maybe they’ve been protecting another kind of species, like a queen bee?

After discovering six hidden cameras at her piggery earlier this year, Ms Beveridge claimed to feel personally violated and terrified by the incidents.

The young mum and wife now believes animal activists have illegally entered her property at least eight times to try and find fault, while other piggeries have been targeted in similar attacks in the region.

But rather than believing the issue is over now and her family’s life can return to normal, she remains terrified by an enemy determined to operate in the dead of night and remain at arm’s length from legal scrutiny.

Believing the best way to catch the activists is red-handed due to largely futile laws, Ms Beveridge tried to invoke a citizen’s arrest after discovering the hidden cameras in April.

She set a trap and the alarm bells sounded on May 12 at about 12.50am, when the activists were disrupted in the process of breaking into the shed.

Ms Beveridge said she called the police first but before the law could arrive, a contingent of about eight volunteers from the piggery spent about fur hours searching valiantly for the intruders.

In contrast, the activists claim they were hunted by the volunteers after they innocently came to investigate conditions at Ms Beveridge’s piggery, in the middle of the night – like Mary Poppins stumbling on the Midnight Rambler.

Their car was parked about one kilometre from the piggery sheds and had its windows smashed and tyres slashed.

Despite the hive of angry activity, no eventual charges were laid over any of the trespasses or damage due to lack of sufficient evidence, to gain a conviction.

The activists claimed to know nothing about the hidden cameras at the time - but they’re now squealing about animal cruelty based on vision obtained in covert operations.

Nearing her wit’s end, Ms Beveridge has since sought an apprehended violence order against Animal Liberation NSW executive director Mark Pearson.

In addition, her industry body has tried other legal avenues to shut down the activist’s anti-pig farming website and launched a counter-information campaign using their own media production skills and internet publishing.

In response to the AVO application, Mr Pearson claims he’s never seen Ms Beveridge or stepped foot on her property - but he certainly claimed intimate knowledge of her business practices in this week’s media statement.

“Ms Beveridge has proven here the sort of violence she feels is acceptable, while trying desperately to prevent this footage from reaching the Australian public,” he said.

Regardless of their apparent good intentions, these butter-wouldn’t-melt-in-their-mou ths activists are surely placing themselves at greater risk of encountering personal harm with each late night visit, especially given the frustrations of farmers like the Beveridges, who feel the law is failing to protect them from these repeated attacks.

Industry members and politicians are growing more and more concerned but they also say a huge legal gap exists around this type of animal activism, to protect farmers properly.

If they’re ever caught, offenders are slapped with light penalties for any subsequent trespass convictions after lengthy and costly legal battles.

In the meantime, the damage inflicted on industry and individual farmers’ reputations using illegally obtained video footage far outweighs any subsequent, belated penalty.

Terrorism laws sit at the other end of the scale, which are generally considered too harsh and extreme for this activity.

Claims that some politicians are considering 'ag-gag' laws, like those introduced in several US states to try and get illegally obtained video footage handed over to proper regulators without unnecessary delays, have also been met with disapproval by animal activists.

Some have signalled they’ll merely unleash more weapons, like remote controlled drones carrying high definition video cameras, to patrol farmers’ properties or livestock feedlots, if tougher laws are enacted.

So where and how does it all end?

Given the lack of legal protection and ever expanding moral badgering and frustration farmers are suffering at the hands of determined animal activists, one can only imagine what could happen if a midnight confrontation or attempted citizen’s arrest went horribly wrong, in a back paddock somewhere.

And one can only imagine how that same scene would unfold, if animal activists decided to venture about 250kms west of Young to a little town called Griffith, to prosecute their high moral internet, media, farming campaigns on some of the more hands-on farmers, in that particular region.

Page:
1
FarmOnline
Date: Newest first | Oldest first

READER COMMENTS

Matt12
23/12/2013 5:11:36 AM

Animal activists are sad little people who have this notion that it's their duty to save the world... get a life.
stockman
22/12/2013 4:42:19 PM

Farmers have nothing to hide but they are busy trying to make a living. Having galoots poking there snouts into something they know nothing about would take up too much of the farmer's time. Plus the odor of the 'activists' could turn the animals off their tucker.
Fence Sitter
21/12/2013 10:20:52 AM

I've never quite understood the 'goody two shoes' or 'do gooder' insults. Is it meant to say that those that try to 'do good' are in some way wrong or mock-worthy?
spaceagesoup
20/11/2013 11:55:22 AM

How bout some balance in the concepts you're presenting, instead of vitriol directed at compassionate individuals who do care.
E J
17/11/2013 6:00:43 PM

Bio security is very high in an animal husbandry situation these days. That is why we don't let any and all in. It is to protect the health of the animals, something these midnight raders don't seem to have considered. No wonder the farmers are upset. A large percentage of the population these days has been brainwashed from school days, and become far removed from reality.
Michael B
12/11/2013 6:50:28 PM

In my view every abattoir should be fitted with permanent CCTV, open for public scrutiny at any time. If the meat workers have nothing to hide, then why should they object. There are CCTV cameras in every pub, shop, hotel, street corner, etc in every city and that certainly helps to solve crime and identify wrongdoers. So lets extend this to abattoirs!!
inverell
12/11/2013 2:05:30 PM

Where have you been living David? When vegans are invited into workplaces like the Giles abattoir recently they purposely stirred up animals then took footage that resulted in them losing their business. Farms have nothing to hide but you never let these people near your business. They want to shut down all animal production and it seem will go to any length to make it happen. Michael & Edwina Beveridge are not red necks they both went to Sydney University and are educated, professional, caring, best practice farmers of the highest calibre.
Nomore
12/11/2013 1:04:06 PM

Totally agreed govegan. The tide is turning and now that the media and activists are exposing farm based cruelty then it's only a matter of time before change is inevitable and farmers are exposed who maintain cruel standards of welfare.
David
12/11/2013 9:46:44 AM

What's with all hate? If the industry and its supporters stopped calling the activists names, stopped with the threats of violence and opened their business to the scrutiny modern consumers demand, the industries would Starve to activists their oxegyn - that is of course presuming their is nothing to hide. If the industries response is to call for draconian US style ag-gag laws, to threaten to kill campaigners and to refuse anything other than "self-regulation" then the need for activism is obvious because their is very very clearly something that they are trying to keep hid.
Corinne
12/11/2013 8:30:38 AM

Cruelty towards animals has been hidden from the public for too long and more and more people won't accept that anymore. I am so happy to see that animal activists around the planet fight for this utterly important cause. I became vegan 4 years ago when I discovered the truth about Factory Farming; I was shocked by a footage I saw about cows in Factory Farming. Luckily the farms won't be able to keep all this cruelty in the shadow. Thanks to the animal activists and to all people who fight to change animal welfare.
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >
Canberra CommentFairfax Agricultural Media Canberra correspondent Colin Bettles tackles the big national rural and agricultural issues which will impact regional and rural Australians.

COMMENTS

light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who