Live ex ALP's millstone

... perhaps they’re not living with the day-to-day reality of the economic and social grief

WHOEVER wins the federal Labor leadership ballot will need to go out and clean up the mess that’s been left behind in rural Australia by the previous government.

Bill Shorten and Anthony Albanese are both faced with a monumental challenge to regain trust and confidence from rural voters and prove their party comprehends the regional landscape, beyond rhetoric.

That healing and recovery process would be turbo-charged by a sincere, heartfelt apology from the new party leader, for banning the live cattle trade to Indonesia in June 2011.

If they can’t or won’t undertake that journey to redemption, the ALP can simply give up now and surrender seats in rural Australia to the Coalition forever.

Some people may say it’s time to move on from the live cattle suspension and even thank the Labor government for the Exporter Supply Chain Assurance Scheme, implemented in response to the animal welfare issues which underpinned the sudden ban.

But perhaps they’re not living with the day-to-day reality of the economic and social grief they’ve been forced to endure in the name of political convenience, forced on the by the ALP while serving a left wing urban vote winning agenda.

An exclusive Fairfax Agricultural Media poll conducted during the federal election campaign saw 64 per cent (696 of 1096 respondents) nominate the trade suspension as a deciding factor on their final vote.

One of the ALP’s chief architects of the suspension Janelle Saffin suffered a 6.8pc swing against her - and subsequently lost her North Coast NSW seat of Page to the National’s Kevin Hogan.

Another Labor back-bencher who undermined party policy by publicly backing a phase out of live exports was Darren Cheeseman, who lost his Corangamite electorate to Liberal Sarah Henderson after suffering a 4.1pc swing against him in the marginal southern Victorian seat.

Western Australian Labor Senator Glenn Sterle chairs the Senate Rural and Regional Transport Affairs Committee and is a former road train operator in northern WA and the Northern Territory.

Senator Sterle said his party had no official plans as yet on how they planned to reclaim lost ground with rural voters, but acknowledged “we’ve got some work to do”.

He said voter confidence in Labor was severely “dented” in regional Australia because of the live cattle suspension.

But the ALP still values the regions “greatly” and views agriculture in particular as being “integral” to the national economy, he said.

“We did some good stuff in the election and announced some good policies but unfortunately the Indonesian cattle ban reflected on us very badly,” he said.

Labor’s Shadow Agriculture Minister Joel Fitzgibbon acknowledged the live cattle ban, or “pause” as he calls it, did cost his party votes this election, not just in the bush.

He said the issue continued to permeate a negative judgment, not only in the beef cattle industry but other sectors of the economy.

Mr Fitzgibbon said other groups were concerned that if Labor could ban the live cattle trade to Indonesia in such an unnerving way – without consulting our trading partners or industry groups and despite departmental warnings of a domestic animal welfare crisis and economic disaster – that type of political sabotage could also occur in their sector.

“It was a significant weight around our necks,” the no-nonsense Hunter MP said.

Mr Fitzgibbon said he apologised for the ban at a beef forum in Mt Isa at north-west Queensland in late July, shortly after being appointed Minister, ahead of the election.

His off-the-cuff speech - made to about 150 graziers - apologised for the ban’s impacts on real people, regardless of the right and wrongs of why it took place.

Mr Fitzgibbon said he couldn’t recall the exact audience reaction on the day, but in the end it failed to spark any kind of voter revolt and the bitter taste still lingers.

To win back voter support in regional Australia, Mr Fitzgibbon believes Labor needs to deliver on the promise of a brighter economic future for farmers, backed by stronger policies aimed at increasing productivity and profitability.

That includes finding ways to improve export market access to capitalise on the Asian “dining boom” that he passionately supports.

“It’s critical to Australia’s economic future that the agricultural sector continues to grow in strength,” he said.

Mr Fitzgibbon said he wished the new Agriculture Minister Barnaby Joyce well and would be giving him “every opportunity to prove himself” while also “keeping a close check on him”.

About 40,000 Labor members are now expected to cast their vote to determine the new Labor leader in coming weeks.

Some of those voters also live in rural areas and may well wish to ensure their choice of new leader is someone who knows where they live, understands how they live and can also eat humble pie.

Colin Bettles

Colin Bettles

is the national political writer for Fairfax Agricultural Media
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


Over the Hill
1/10/2013 12:01:39 PM

Lets not forget the Super Trawler decision made purley to appease a noisy few without conidering the actual facts and benefits of this vessel on the fish stocks.
23/09/2013 10:34:26 AM

Labor lost the rural vote when they got into bed with the radical Greens.Milne may deny it,but the Greens have always been anti farming.
21/09/2013 5:02:57 PM

There will be very little forgiveness from rural Australia for any of the current crop of ALP politicians. The ALP too willingly sided with extremists. The result proves that mainstream Australia does not regard animal activists and their supporters with any regard. They are vocal, noisy and fanatical, but they do not represent mainstream opinion. They never will. Politicians listen to them at their peril, as has been demonstrated at the polls..
The Jackel
21/09/2013 1:54:36 PM

We need profitability foremost,that will always sort out future production needsThe problem i see from the city to the country trades retailers farmers etc everyone is hurting no money Why, interest rates low not much change Record exports nothing for us Perhaps the money is not in the system so where is it Super funds have massive sums tied up so what if reserve bank released similar amount back into economy like the yanks did would it help Floging off more assetts cheap is not the answer.We must make our own answer sumhow
21/09/2013 11:35:09 AM

Exactly. They were warned about the impact a temp ban would have, yet went ahead eschewing more constructive diplomatic options. Clearest case of policy failure you'll hear. Ex Indonesian ambassador Bill Farmer seems to agree. Great article Colin.
Paul Cox
21/09/2013 10:28:55 AM

As usual Colin Bettles has his finger on the pulse of rural Australia. At least Joel Fitzgibbon can see the reality but how many other ALP pollies can see past their internal issues to what actually matters to not just rural Australia but the vast majority?
Canberra CommentFairfax Agricultural Media Canberra correspondent Colin Bettles tackles the big national rural and agricultural issues which will impact regional and rural Australians.


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who