Pulped fiction hurts farmers

It’s time to wipe your mouth and get a bit of s**t on your boots

I FIND it sad when people make decisions about what to eat or not to eat based on assumptions or skewed information about agricultural production. Many vegans, especially in Australia, are an example of this worrying trend.

It’s hard for people to determine the difference between information that is universally true and that which confirms their bias or values – but even with that in mind, it must take a brain devoid of inquisitiveness to shift ingrained behaviour like eating habits to suit a belief based on misinformation and no personal experience.

Add to that the side-serving of conditioning that many vegans try to deliver and you've got a message hard to digest - case in point is columnist Sam De Brito.

De Brito writes for Fairfax metros The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age. On Saturday he published a piece labelled “confessions of a vegan”. It demonstrated a soft spot for ignorance and a taste for truly heinous art. If you’ve read De Brito before, you may be familiar with his adjective-laden style and self righteous tone.

With a view of Australian farming which seems purely derived from activist propaganda, he went to town plugging a cause built on generalisation, misinformation and outright lies to put an end to farming animals.

His article led me to believe that De Brito assumes all farming is ‘factory farming’. It makes mention of “spooning the misery of other creatures into my mouth” and claims the “food you so blithely eat actually causes massive, lifelong, completely avoidable suffering to billions of animals”.

This is news to me, and I work in the industry.

This kind of diatribe makes my blood boil - it adds fuel to the fire of misinformation that rips through urban Australia without shedding new light on the issue.

And the issue here to me is that De Brito’s reckless writing - along with that of others equally as gullible and artless - reaches (even influences) audiences also unaware of what actually happens in their own primary industries. They would have us take up the most unrealistic, unsustainable, inefficient and uneconomical methods as solutions to incidents far removed from their comprehension.

On Sunday, ABC Landline's Pip Courtney interviewed filmmaker Michael Dahlstrom, whose film The Animal Condition just premiered at the Melbourne Film Festival. It charts the journey of animal welfare in Australia from a fringe issue to major community concern. What started out as an activist-driven film to expose parts of Australian animal production that use intensive farming, changed tack as Michael spoke with farmers and saw for himself the complexity of the issues involved. He’s reserved judgement and now also leaves that up to the viewer.

It’ll be great to see an independent movie that leaves the sensationalised (and often US-inspired) views behind to let audiences have a tiny snapshot into the issue and those factions of Australian agriculture that farm intensively.

I was once hauled over the coals by angry readers for likening the propaganda and tactics of animal activist groups to Hitler's Nazi regime. While I had no intention of causing offence to Holocaust survivors and victims, I stand by that analogy - and see some activists use the same language. The Animal Holocaust exhibition by Gold Coast artist Jo Fredricks is applauded and recommended by De Brito in his article.

And while I may not know art, I know what I like - this particular exhibition, dare I say it, is a bit too “Gold Coast” for my taste.

Last October De Brito wrote a very ‘pro-farming’ piece that spruiked an industry which successfully feeds and clothes Australia - and millions more. In that piece he wrote how “easy (it is) to forget there's a vast green, brown and red expanse of agricultural land inside the coastal ring of our cities that fills our bellies and contributes $36 billion to our exports”.

He warned readers they’d hear more of agriculture with Nationals leader Warren Truss now the Deputy PM and even expressed a wish “to learn how to operate a Massey combine harvester” and speculated: "Who knows, we might even see the odd animal husbandry course inserted into compulsory subjects along such 'real world' lessons as balancing a budget or applying for a personal loan?"

I offered to take Sam out to drive a harvester, but never heard back. After Saturday's article, I’d offer again to show him around some farms that produce some of the best food in the world to the highest global standards - without compromising animal health.

Either way, Sam, it’s about time to wipe your mouth and get a bit of s**t on your boots.

Read Sam de Brito's 'Confessions of a vegan'

Sam Trethewey

Sam Trethewey

grew up farming down south and now commentates on agriculture across Australia
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


16/08/2014 8:46:22 AM

Frank Blunt: The similarity has been noted by anthropologists.
Frank Blunt
15/08/2014 1:30:44 PM

I guess that makes the climate change worry warts a religion as well Qlander. They are good at shoving their global warming gospel down peoples throats.
15/08/2014 1:11:01 PM

Good Article, but. Firstly, I am not a vegan. But I've done a little research into them. Not all vegans are the same from what i learnt. The reasons they have gone vegan vary from their own values, to health reasons. Some may seem idealistic. But at the end of the day, they have as much right to be vegan as we all do to not be vegan. I do enjoy straw man comments. I understand the view point you're coming from. but please don't $**t on other people because they don't conform to your way of living. At the same time I do agree with having life skills like farming in schools.
15/08/2014 12:13:14 PM

Tim: Vegans exist because of the decline of the old main stream religions. There is something about humans, that they. A need a religion and B need to shove their religion down everyone's throat.
15/08/2014 8:05:21 AM

As a grazier, I have to admit that I quite like many vegetarian, and even vegan dishes. They just need to be served ON a rump steak, with chips, and a fried egg on top
Bil Natas
15/08/2014 6:21:08 AM

I have a question for vegans Have the ever seen a Kangaroo or hair or a wombat or an emu in a vegetable paddock? NO! WHY? The cocky SHOOTS THEM. So there is Slaughter of animals to produce vegetables. Ducks on the pond Bil
9/08/2014 10:14:03 AM

Vegans exist to bring attention to the unnecessary exploitation, abuse, cruelty, and violence inflicted on other animal species for human gain and profit. Vegans reject years of social and cultural conditioning through industry propaganda. I'm a vegan and support farming, but not harming. Nobody needs to suffer and die so that we can live healthy and happy lives. There are peaceful and nonviolent alternatives that don't involve enslavement, oppression, and violence towards other sentient beings see www.veganeasy.org for more details
7/08/2014 12:19:46 PM

Jack, your post highlights the philosophical shallowness of veganism. Just because you choose to do no harm, does not mean that this is the outcome in the real world. Fact is that the livestock on my side of the fence, are far better off than they would be in nature. Mine lead a leisurely lifestyle, are protected from attack by worms, predators, diseases, are fed through droughts and don't starve to death from hunger. Unlike those in nature, which you might not harm, but hardly lead the cushy life my livestock do. My livestock don't suffer your problem of fear of death either.
7/08/2014 11:55:05 AM

North America Indians ate meat as did the Eskimos and didn't get cancer but their lifestyle was vastly different to ours . Eskimos did eat a lot of fish but I not sure if they ate veggies , where would they have had access to them.
Jack Hateya
7/08/2014 10:23:45 AM

Jen from the bush, veganism is about doing as little harm as possible to the other animals with which we share this planet. Unfortunately there are animal casualties and fatalities during plant-based food production, there's no point trying to deny it. The issue though, is whether or not you ACTIVELY choose to have animals exploited and/or slaughtered on your behalf. Then there's the fact that animals raised for meat, dairy and eggs eat far more plant matter than any vegan or vegetarian ever could, exponentially increasing the death toll caused by those who eat animal products.
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5  |  next >
Get MuddyTo think clearly in farming and about farming, you need to get muddy - commit, roll up your sleeves and get involved. SAM TRETHEWEY gets stuck into some of the issues facing those on the land.


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who