Ag in policy wilderness

Agriculture policy in the first year of the Abbott government has been most marked by inertia

I’VE been waiting for Barnaby Joyce to take the credit for the Nick Kyrgios win over Rafael Nadal - he seems to have already claimed just about everything else.

Debating me recently in the Parliament, he took credit for everything from Western Australia’s bumper wheat harvest, through to the success of Labor’s Farm Finance package, and increases in live cattle exports. He also says he’s saved farmers from the impacts of drought!

The Ag Minister would have farming families believe he’s a miracle worker but in reality, he’s more like a snake oil salesman. I recently challenged Barnaby to name one government initiative since his appointment which has led to an increase in live exports. His silence has been deafening.

The Minister likes to talk about the impact of the 2011 pause in cattle exports to Indonesia. He says “we are getting exports going again”. But the live trade pause was three years ago - and exports have been recovering for some time.

That’s mainly because the Indonesians have been relaxing their import quotas. The quota system started to hit in 2010 (prior to the export pause) when a 350 kilogram weight restriction on cattle imports was first imposed and import permits were curtailed. This had the effect of reducing import numbers by 32 per cent.

The quota set for 2011 was 500,000 head but a tonnage ceiling was also imposed with significant impact. The head quota subsequently fell to 283,000 and 267,000 in 2012 and 2013. These quotas reflected the Indonesian government’s desire to increase self-sufficiency. However the government in Jakarta later indicated it will accept 750,000 head during 2014.

In addition to the relaxation of import restrictions, the $60 million package the then Prime Minister Kevin Rudd took to Jakarta in July 2013 is now having a positive effect on our live trade numbers.

I’ve often said that the live trade pause was regrettable. But it also gave birth to the best animal welfare system in the world. Now, whenever Barnaby Joyce announces he’s hoping to open new markets, he cites that same animal welfare system as the initiative which makes securing new markets possible.

I need not go into Barnaby Joyce taking credit for Western Australia’s bumper wheat harvest or for Labor’s Farm Finance package. But what about the drought assistance?

Back in February drought was a front-page story most days. We couldn’t turn on morning television without hearing about it. Newspapers, radio stations and others were launching efforts to establish drought relief funds. It was a red-hot issue - and a problem for the Abbott government.

Then came Tony Abbott’s drought tour and soon after, an announcement of a new drought package. The centrepiece was a $280 million concessional loans scheme, modelled on Labor’s Farm Finance scheme. While the media stories disappeared the drought did not and the problem is, not one farming family has yet secured a loan under the new drought scheme.

Agriculture policy in the first year of the Abbott government has been most marked by inertia. While we wait for the much vaunted Agriculture White Paper, all policy remains on hold. And almost every agriculture-related bill which has passed this Parliament originated in the last Parliament.

But I should not sell Barnaby Joyce short. I acknowledge three achievements.

First, the Agriculture Minister is the only senior member of the government to publicly acknowledge that the Japan Free Trade Agreement sells agriculture short. It’s a sentiment he shares with both me and the sector.

Second, he has embarked on a new decentralisation policy – the centrepiece is the relocation of his ministerial office from Sydney to Armidale. It’s a move which will give Barnaby a presence in the two major towns in his electorate – one in Tamworth and one in Armidale.

Third, he has increased agriculture research and development by $100 million over four years. But the problem is he’s taken almost that much out of other agriculture-related research and development programs – in the CSIRO, our Co-operative Research Centres and the Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation. He’s robbed Peter to pay Paul.

Let’s hope the Agriculture White Paper (being developed by the Prime Minister’s Department) pulls a rabbit out of a hat because so far, it’s been a dry argument for agriculture in more ways than one.

However if the delay of the Green Paper is indicative of the White Paper progress, the Agricultural sector, certainly shouldn’t hold its breath.

Joel Fitzgibbon

Joel Fitzgibbon

is Shadow Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries & Forestry & Rural Affairs and the MP for Hunter
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


Just another farmer
16/07/2014 5:34:33 AM

Instead of running him down, tell us what you would do if you were minister. The shadow of the "EXPORT PAUSE" will rightly hang over your party for ever. The Labor party can never have the interests of farmers at heart. It was founded by a group of striking pastoral workers and the anti rural platform still exists in their DNA and always will.
16/07/2014 7:08:39 AM

" the live trade pause was regrettable" Now there is a statement from someone who really has no understanding of the toxic chain of events that "pause" (it used to be a suspension) caused and amplified. Livestock sales didn't PAUSE in the North , they stopped! Land sales didn't PAUSE in the North - they STOPPED!. Banks didn't PAUSE lending in the North - they STOPPED! People didn't PAUSE earning income, they STOPPED. Businesses servicing the Beef industry in the North didn't PAUSE - they STOPPED. Joel it takes more than a pair of RMWs to understand the bush!!
16/07/2014 7:10:38 AM

"...the live trade "pause" was regrettable…" yeah , good one Joel. I can think of a more easily interpretable term for what Labour did to the live export trade, but it wouldn't be printable. You've miss-named your blog sir, it should be called a "blah-blah"
Northern Exporter
16/07/2014 7:57:00 AM

Joel, the greatest trade barrier we currently have is ESCAS and your Government put that in place; however Barnaby has not done one thing to replace it, which needs to be asap. With regard to Indonesia, you should raise in the House the matter of the Processors in Australia dumping meat in Indo. and undercutting the Australian cattle coming out of Indo feedlots by $1 per kilo at least, using MLA levy funds from producer live exporters to promote the dumped meat to our financial detriment. This is not to mention the disastrous cattle prices being paid domesticity to fund the dumping
16/07/2014 10:52:50 AM

Unfortunately, Barnaby is subject to a control obsessed leader. He's not permitted to move on his own initiative and his leader is urban centric. The fact that the White Paper is being developed in the Prime Ministers Department does not offer much hope.
16/07/2014 11:27:31 AM

I am in violent agreement with you "Just another farmer".
16/07/2014 3:52:12 PM

What a load of bollocks from a party that did its best to destroy the live cattle trade without any conscience. An Mr Fitgibbon forgets several free trade agreements that stalled for five years whilst the Mad Hatters ran the country. Now thank goodness there are some free trade agreements concluded and others in an advanced stage of negotiation. The cheek of this wally is unbelievable!!
Out of the shadowShadow Agriculture Minister Joel Fitzgibbon aims to put ag policy under the microscope. Based in the NSW Hunter Valley, Joel also has a unique perspective on the tensions between primary production and mining development.


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who