Ag levy motions withdrawn from Senate

24 Sep, 2014 02:05 PM
Senator David Leyonhjelm. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
We thank the Greens for their acumen in this debate
Senator David Leyonhjelm. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

AUSTRALIAN horticulture and agriculture leaders have welcomed news that motions to oppose the hard-fought changes to statutory levies have today been withdrawn in the Senate, after the matter was postponed last month.

The mango, onion and mushroom levy changes have been well supported by the federal government, with Agriculture Minister Barnaby Joyce showing leadership by approving the changes for inclusion in the May budget.

The levy disallowance motions, foreshadowed by Senator David Leyonhjelm, have been withdrawn, with the Greens publicly declaring their opposition to the motions, quickly followed by the Palmer United Party (PUP), and the ALP’s shadow agriculture minister also voicing his opposition to the disallowance motions.

Leyonhjelm 'not correct' on majority

Interestingly, Senator Leyonhjelm continues to state that “the support from the majority of levy payers in each of these industries was missing”.

This is not correct, as the changes were voted on by the levy payers of each industry and required majority support to pass.

The levy system underpins Australia’s agricultural research and development, marketing, and plant and animal health systems that have made our nation one of the leading agricultural producers in the world.

The industries conducted a rigorous five-year process of consultation, investing grower funds and conducting Australian Electorial Commission or independent ballots.

The Greens announced they would not support any motion that would threaten the future of Australia’s agriculture levy system, stating they understood increases and amendments to the levies were supported by growers and provided important investments in their industries.

Agriculture industries respond

Onions Australia levy champion Brian Bonde welcomed Senator Leyonhjelm’s decision to withdraw his motions.

Mr Bonde said the government and a number of other parties had recognised Australian farmers were trying to help themselves and secure their future.

“The Greens and PUP have seen that Australian farmers are doing their best to invest in their own future and have come on board to ensure that not only continues, but thrives,” he said.

“The levy changes have been requested by growers, to invest for the benefit of all levy payers and have been approved by a majority of growers in these three industries, having followed rigorous and transparent government consultation guidelines.

“With some of the lowest agricultural subsidies in the world, the levy system is the best way to keep Australian horticulture and agriculture funding their future in a self-sufficient way.

“We congratulate the Greens and PUP, in conjunction with the federal government, for assuring Aussie farmers that they have our backs.”

Australian Mango Industry Association CEO Robert Gray welcomed the withdrawal of the motions.

“It's been very satisfying to be part of a united across-horticulture group which together have worked to achieve a great outcome for all stakeholders, growers, government and the Australian public,” he said.

Australian Mushroom Growers Association general manager Greg Seymour said it had fast become clear the Senate would reject the disallowance motions, with Senators acknowledging the rigorous and demanding administrative process all three industries had undergone.

“It has also confirmed the importance of the agricultural levy system to underpin the international competitiveness of Australia’s agricultural industries,” he said.

“We thank the government for acting on our industry’s request for a levy increase and leading the fight for common sense. We thank the Greens for their acumen in this debate and all the Senators who displayed their wisdom by publicly stating their intention to vote against the disallowance motions.”

Date: Newest first | Oldest first


25/09/2014 6:50:39 AM

Well done democracy! The true actions of Senator Leyonhjelm have been exposed. And he still promotes the wrong view of those directly involved in Ag industtries.
25/09/2014 7:09:43 AM

Round one lost, but not the war. G.R.D.C. is an excellent case in point. Huge amounts of glossy paper and not a lot to show for it. Certainly not value for $. Look back and read--- neral-news/raising-the-bar-for-ha rvest-efficiency/2712305.aspx?utm _source=newsletter&utm_medium=ema il&utm_campaign=newsletter
25/09/2014 7:52:27 AM

Gecko, If only the levies I paid allowed for democratic identification, voting and control of the levy expenditure. If you think you have democracy in Australian Ag Industries then we are all stuffed!!
angry australian
25/09/2014 8:55:51 AM

Gecko, in your democracy you have unrepresentative groups using people's money to further their own needs using the force of government. Sounds like a dictatorship to me! Leaving all that aside, there has been literally $billions poured into these groups over the years, aren't we entitled to ask when the benefits will flow through to the primary producers? At the moment these organisations just appear to be a funding source for researchers and just another layer of red tape and expensive pseudo bureaucracy on industry. If government is convinced of the benefits why doesn't the taxpayer fund them?
25/09/2014 10:07:01 AM

Angry is right. The R&D expenditure made from the levies should have return on investment that comes back to all the levy payers. Has anyone received a dividend cheque for all the adopted R&D that we were told had a triple bottom line benefit?? Oh!! That's right someone else got the benefit of the R&D for free!!
25/09/2014 2:08:30 PM

wondering why they aren't at least subject to periodic review? to me, if worthy, one should not be scared of accountability from time to time.
26/09/2014 8:00:04 AM

Democracy my tail..... primary producers don't even have a Bill of Rights in this country. With this type of thinking in power we need a small farmers union representative body. Compulsory acquisition without any requirement of return to all/any contributor , and no valid avenue for input as to how contribution is spent.. does not fit with democracy.


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who