Ag still waiting for its workforce

03 Mar, 2015 01:00 AM
There are plenty of stories across the industry about the value of temporary workers from overseas

THE mining industry might not be sucking as many rural sector skills and workers from farms and farm service business as it did five years ago, but agriculture is still struggling to find the staff it needs.

Pay rates for top ag sector graduates jumped 26.2 per cent last financial year, indicative of how agribusinesses - particularly corporates - have been forced to raise the stakes significantly to attract new talent.

Even regions squeezed hard by recent drought seasons can't get enough machinery mechanics and light engineering skills to meet current demands, let alone cope with a bumper year.

Unskilled workers continue to be in short supply, too, prompting the federal government's moves to free up some restrictions on guest workers from South Pacific countries to fill harvest season jobs in the horticulture, cane and cotton sectors.

The changes, applauded the National Farmers' Federation (NFF), do not lift the seasonal workers program cap above 12,000, but will allow different industries greater flexibility to employ more help within that quota.

"Grey nomads and backpackers have traditionally been a common feature of the seasonal labour pool for fruit growers, but now they're increasingly helping fill the labour gap in broadacre cropping areas, too," said Tractor and Machinery Association executive director Richard Lewis.

"There are plenty of stories across the industry about the value of temporary workers from overseas - unskilled and skilled - filling jobs on farms or with machinery dealers and harvest contractors."

Ireland in particular, had been a solid source of workers for the machinery industry employed under special arrangements such as the employer-sponsored 457 temporary migration visa.

Mr Lewis said many moved on or returned home after three or four years, but some remained making a valuable contribution to farming communities particularly where employers were otherwise frequently losing staff to nearby mining sector roles.

System inflexible

But while work visas can be extended for skilled machinery technicians, Dubbo-based territory manager with Chesterfield Australia, David Searston, said gaining permanent residency wasn't a cheap process, especially for applicants from non-English speaking backgrounds, which was not unusual in the machinery game.

The system was also surprisingly inflexible for older workers, no matter how good they were at their job.

Mr Searston has three valued 457 visa employees working at the John Deere dealership's Coonamble and Warren sites, two from Eastern Europe.

He said without the broad experience and guidance provided by his well qualified 457 staff he could not employ at least two local apprentices.

"We advertised for six months and couldn't get an Australian to fill a plant mechanic's job at Coonamble, but these blokes really work - they'd work 24 hours a day if they were asked," he said.

However, applying for full residency cost about $17,000 to cover multiple application requirement processes.

"That's not easy money to find for somebody with a young family earning an agricultural diesel mechanic's wage (typically starting from around $65,000 a year), without any health support from Medicare," he said.

Age barriers

Even more frustrating, employees over 50 had few chances of achieving permanent residency status.

Polish Masters graduate in science and electromagnetics Leszek Michna arrived at Warren via a John Deere dealership in Ireland's County Limerick in 2012, yet despite a strong work record and qualifications his various visa conversion attempts have been blocked by immigration authorities because he is now 55.

"His work ethic is unbelievable, his experience includes working on helicopters, planes and lecturing uni students and he wants to stay in Warren," said Mr Searston, noting few skilled young people who took up to mining sector jobs seemed keen to return home to fixing tractors despite mining employment options now drying up.

Rural job placement specialist Ray Johnson at Agricultural Appointments said while his firm had seen some increased inquiry from people with five to seven years mining sector experience, many rural employers were reluctant to take them back.

"These workers might be quite skilled in operational or logistics roles, but their specific experience and pay hopes don't necessarily fit with the ag sector any more," he said.

"The farm machinery industry could probably take quite a few people with mining sector experience, but maybe there's a fairly big expectation gap to get over first."

Andrew Marshall

Andrew Marshall

is the national agribusiness writer for Fairfax Agricultural Media
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


angry australian
3/03/2015 6:14:49 AM

The farm machinery industry may well afford 457 staff and ex miners but farmers just aren't in the hunt. The conditions that governments and unions have imposed on employers may suit white collar and governments jobs but have been a huge contributor to the shutting of our food factories and abattoirs which were our customers. Heinz,Safcol,Edgell,Golden Circle,SPC, Tom Piper etc all had canneries, how many exist today? Weekly there are stories of growers being raided by immigration and the ATO as they try and cut costs. Further mechanisation,robotics etc will be the only way we can survive
3/03/2015 6:38:02 AM

More to the point Ag is still struggling to find the money, to pay the staff it needs.
3/03/2015 7:13:43 AM

If Ag enterprises can only survive by workers have rubbish wages/conditions - it aint going to end pretty.
Harvest Trail program
3/03/2015 8:11:10 AM

The Harvest Trail program is funded by the taxpayer to direct unskilled workers to farms, mainly horticulture but also cropping enterprises. Backpackers use it the most, but also grey nomads and other locals access jobs this way, but how many farmers are using it? Today (3/3/15) in NSW there are only 2 jobs requiring 25 people listed. Are farms really having difficulty filling jobs, or are they just repeating the media stories they hear? Most jobs listed on the Harvest Trail website that require unskilled farm workers are filled within 24 hours, so long as budget accommodation is available.
3/03/2015 8:28:12 AM

What a joke! I have to pay my workers what the government tells me ,but then have to accept low prices that multinational business offer me.only I have to compete with the likes of China and India that do not have award rates,insurance,work safe,quality assurance,animal welfare standards etc,etc,etc
jen from the bush
3/03/2015 11:15:28 AM

IF only we could move our farms o/s - be gone years ago.
3/03/2015 3:01:35 PM

Jen, why not just sell the one you have and buy one o/s? It is easy to pay 3rd world wages - in the 3rd world.
Sir Les P
3/03/2015 7:13:37 PM

We might have to wait until miners & CSG workers re-adjust their thinking on what they're worth per day. Many are still in the clouds.


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who