FDI crackdown a 'shambles'

27 Feb, 2015 04:35 AM
Senator Sam Dastyari. Photo: Nick Moir
How can the policy not be in place 100 hours before it is to be implemented?
Senator Sam Dastyari. Photo: Nick Moir

THE Abbott government's foreign investment crackdown looks shaky after Labor reserved judgment on whether it will support the plan, which includes tougher fees and penalties, some of which start on Monday without any draft law in sight.

From March 1, 2015, the Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB) will also scrutinise foreign purchases of Australian agricultural land worth $15 million or more, down from the high threshold of $252 million.

But a Senate estimates inquiry on Thursday heard the FIRB is yet to include any details of the policy change on its website and the government is yet to introduce any legislation to make the change legal.

In addition, the definition of agricultural land is being reviewed over the coming months and the final decision will be applied retrospectively to all transactions from March 1.

"The whole thing is a shambles," Labor senator Sam Dastyari said.

"How can the policy not be in place 100 hours before it is to be implemented? It starts on Monday so how could the rules not be in place?"

A proposed $5000 application fee for foreign buyers for properties worth up to $1 million, rising to $10,000 and beyond for properties worth more than $1 million, is estimated to raise $200 million a year, with the expectation it would fund better enforcement activities by the FIRB.

But only a day after Treasurer Joe Hockey and Prime Minister Tony Abbott announced the proposal on Wednesday ahead of four weeks of consultation, it emerged the fee levels and expected revenue raised could change again, along with how the government will spend the money.

A bipartisan parliamentary inquiry recommended a $1500 fee to cover FIRB activities. But Mr Hockey told ABC Radio on Thursday that Coalition backbenchers had complained foreigners should be charged more to apply to buy Australian homes.

"We consulted with colleagues in the Liberal and National parties and their very strong view was that $1500 is not enough," he said.

"Well, it's based on consultations already; we said it's up to $5000. Now, if the community comes back and says $5000 is too much for a foreign investor to buy a $900,000 home or unit, then we'll take that into account. That's why we go through this consultation process."

In Senate estimates hearings, Treasury chief operating officer John Lonsdale said the $200 million estimate for possible revenue collected from the new fee was not an official forecast.

He said the revenue collected depended on whether the government made any changes to the fee amounts and whether it even went ahead with the application fees at all after consulting with the property industry and the community.

Mr Lonsdale said there was no guarantee the revenue would be extra funding for FIRB because the application fees may go to fund a new investigative unit within the Australian Taxation Office to look at acquisitions by foreigners.

Liberal Senator Simon Birmingham said it depended on the government's final "landing point" after the consultation period.

Date: Newest first | Oldest first


Bushie Bill
27/02/2015 5:47:01 AM

Will this be the Bunny and Joking Joe's swan song; their last stuff-up before we bid them and their careers farewell? We could get lucky.
Jock Munro
27/02/2015 6:44:13 AM

It would appear that nothing much is sacred in our Federal parliament. You would think that the message from the public on the foreign buy out of our key strategic assets was loud and clear.
27/02/2015 6:44:15 AM

Yeah, Wabbit and Joe are no match for the ALP destroying our country. Can't wait for Shorten and the CFMEU to rule again!
27/02/2015 8:54:11 AM

Another example of this governments inability to get much right. Say what you like LWNJ the previous government continued to pass effective legislation through the parliament whilst at the same time having to deal with an opposition that acted disgracefully .Since assuming the mantle of government they really haven't changed, no policies, no morals, no idea.They can't keep living in the past and blaming everybody else for their problems. Abbott needs to be replaced and a good shakeup of the cabinet for our country to stand a chance. His leadership (or lack of it) is destroying the coalition.
2/03/2015 8:17:43 PM

Whilst time is wasted debating thresholds, like an incurable cancer, our valuable farmland is lost, bit by bit, to foreign interests hourly. By 2050 China won't be able to feed itself. Food produced by Chinese owned farms here will be called upon. Our land will produce food we can't access, whilst we eat crap grown elsewhere! Foreign ownership of our agricultural land is a pathway to catastrophe.
2/03/2015 8:18:39 PM

How much land can a foreigner own in Japan?
Bushie Bill
5/03/2015 5:12:59 PM

Who cares how much land a foreigner can own in Japan, and how is it relevant?


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who