NBN nice, 3G a must

08 Jul, 2013 02:00 AM

FOR farmers, the NBN is a nice idea, but a better mobile network is a necessity.

This message, that mobile coverage for farmers has moved from the category of "handy to have" to "essential service", was regularly repeated at last week's Digital Rural Futures conference in Armidale.

And it was made plain that there is a new "digital divide" being formed, between those who have good access to mobile networks, and those who don't.

Those with good mobile coverage can effectively harness the vast mobile app market and the computing power of "the cloud", which allows people to use a seamlessly-linked ecosystem of digital devices.

Those sitting outside the network are confined to the desktop, an area of computing that is being eclipsed by the investment in mobile.

There were a billion smartphones in use around the world in 2012, with a billion more forecast to be sold in 2013.

A third of Australia's population now uses a smartphone, one of the highest smartphone market penetrations in the world.

The value of smartphones and tablets lies not with the hardware, but the apps, the software programs that make the devices into a customisable portable computer.

And the power of many apps lies in their ability to work seamlessly through a network, so that a device in someone's hand is a portal into the cloud.

For all the bandwidth advantages of the NBN, mobile devices - already becoming the default computer for many - must access the NBN, and "the cloud", through a wifi network. Building a farm-wide network is impractical for most farmers.

As someone at the Digital Rural Futures conference succinctly put it, the difference between the NBN and mobile networks is that the NBN provides for the "connected homestead"; the mobile network provides the "connected ute".

The ute - or the tractor cab - is increasingly where farm business is being conducted. At least, for those who have mobile coverage.

As the Armidale conference heard, large swathes of Australia's farming areas have patchy mobile reception at best, no mobile coverage at worst.

Where there is coverage, bandwidth is often an issue.

"We've had a dis-adoption of technology in some places," said Tim Neale, a director of PrecisionAgriculture.com.

"In Western Australia, we've heard that when miners come off shift and start checking Facebook there is so much demand on the Next G service that tractors operating off the same towers stop auto-steering."

Mr Neale said that progressive farmers with ready access to mobile coverage have an immediate productivity advantage over those that don't.

Mobile coverage can mean the difference between adoption of the proven tools of precision agriculture, and those technologies falling outside the farm's cost-benefit equation.

With a tsunami of new technology headed down the pipe, those with coverage will be at a growing advantage to those without, despite the NBN.

NSW Farmers Association president Fiona Simson said the NBN will be good for regional towns, but of dubious benefit to those outside the fibre footprint.

"The NBN WiFi towers are going up in the same places as the older towers," Ms Simson said.

"They aren't actually increasing the coverage, so that all we're doing is increasing the services to people who already have services. We're doing nothing for the people out there who don't have a service. They will get NBN satellite, but that's relatively limited."

"We have to reprioritise investment. Mobile coverage is an essential service these days."

Telstra erects new mobile towers based on the business case for their usage.

Ms Simson thinks the business case for many regions is changing as people adopt technology. As Mr Neale said, on some connected farms it is not uncommon to have 10-20 devices carrying a SIM card.

There is also a case for government chipping in some of the cost of new towers based on mobile coverage becoming an essential service, Ms Simson said.

"NSWFA did a survey of farmers and found that fixed line copper is still a high priority. But that's because many farmers don't have mobile coverage, and they are scared that if the copper isn't maintained, they'll lose all their services."

"If we want land to be productive, and to encourage rural and regional development, then government has to start standing behind it. The mobile service is something that's relatively easy to fix."

"Let's not just accept that people are leaving the bush and write it off."

Telstra was unable to comment on expansion of the Next G network in time for this article.

Date: Newest first | Oldest first


8/07/2013 10:05:58 AM

No farmers will get fibre NBN. Wireless and Sat are the only options. I have Sat now because I don't have mobile coverage. The Sat NBN is rubbish and no one cares. I have contacted both main pol parties and neither care that it’s not up to scratch. The Nationals don't seem to have any policy to improve either mobile or internet coverage for farmers. You cannot run a business successfully now without good mobile coverage and internet. I don't have either and by the looks of it won't get it either. NBN Sat is a joke and needs more speed and capacity.
8/07/2013 1:09:05 PM

On Telstra access map our farm was shown as have excellent access to mobile. In reality it is poor or nonexistant. It has been the same since the beginning of mobile service. Telstra just changes coverage maps without checking. After pointing out the inaccurate coverage map I was told I would need a car phone antenna. Can see myself walking around with one attached to my shoulder or quad.
8/07/2013 1:47:27 PM

We have NBN satellite coverage , what a joke. There needs to be a review because the Gov have been conned and it is not delivering as promised
8/07/2013 4:46:23 PM

Yes just the same hear in Southern Tablelands. If you dont live close to a major Town, you are stuffed. Also agree Satelite NBN is a Joke, little beter than dial-up.
8/07/2013 4:47:43 PM

Your NBN satelite coverage is a joke at the moment because it is only the interim satelite, we have to wait until about 2015 for the new satelites to be launched. These new satelites will be faster and have a larger capacity.
9/07/2013 5:26:01 AM

Sometimes I despair of Australia ever catching up with the rest of the world in com-tech. Here in Oz we have Telstra jealously guarding their 4G and not allowing wholesale access to it by other companies and some companies still stuck in the 2G rut in some places. All of this while overseas they are preparing for 5G to be released. At the same time, we get 3G from Telstra which in our rural community is overloaded to hell and in spite of the fact that I can see the tower through my office window, there are times when, even with a large external antenna, we get reception closer to dial up!
9/07/2013 5:34:41 AM

Only Labor could throw away our economic advantage in a down turn, on the WOW factor for their supporters. 30% of voters are public servants. Add on the uni culture and the centrelink culture. NOW look at Steven Conroy's belligerent defense of the NBN, and you'll see a spoiled brat in a toy store, screaming at his mother to buy him the latest and the greatest so he can be the first to have one. Do you you really believe any of these people give a damn about our mobile. They certainly don't care about the economy.
9/07/2013 6:18:27 AM

That's what they are saying Geoff. But the new ones will only offer 12mbps. The fibre NBN is 100mbps. That is not competing with the rest of the community is it? My Sat now is slower than ADSL in the city and costs nearly twice as much. By the time we get the new Satellites, if at all,everyone else will be so far ahead again we still can't compete. I have a very fast computer and currently have to wait to see pages download, even pages like the land. I don't think it’s any better than the previous Sat I had with IPSTAR, except it’s a little cheaper.
Bushie Bill
9/07/2013 9:51:46 AM

Grow up, gabby, and try to develop some sense of balance and objectivity. The world doesn't need any more mindless morons.


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who