No 'quick fix' to finding new beef markets

30 Nov, 2011 02:00 AM

THERE is no silver bullet solution for northern beef producers looking for alternative markets to live exports, according to Department of Agriculture and Food (DAFWA) beef leader Brad McCormick.

Mr McCormick told the WA Northern Beef Forum in Broome last week that there was a need to implement change in the industry through long-term planning and investments.

"There are options for beef producers in the north of WA but many of them are long-term solutions and are not a quick fix," Mr McCormick said.

Mr McCormick began by discussing the potential challenges that currently face the northern beef industry.

"The number one challenge is the looming supply issue that has come about after a number of years of drought," Mr McCormick said.

"Just last year around 145,000 head of cattle were trucked over east and half of these were female."

He added that the dominant market, live export, was now under threat and was no longer a stable and sure option for northern producers.

"Not only are producers dealing with this volatility but with no local processing plant and the cost of trucking to the southern processors, there are limited options for beef producers up here to seek alternative markets for their cattle," Mr McCormick added.

But he said it wasn't all doom and gloom, with price initiated confidence seeing pastoralists in the region holding on to their heifers and cows.

"We have seen a drop of around 15-20 per cent of female sales this year compared to the last 10-15 years," Mr McCormick said.

Animal welfare was also becoming an increasing challenge in the industry in the north especially in the wake of the Four Corners report on the live export trade to Indonesia.

"The high reliance on live export to Indonesia meant that when the ban was put in place in June many producers lost their only market," Mr McCormick said.

"It is a very risky situation for them to be in."

Mr McCormick said there were also added challenges around meeting the right specifications for southern processors.

"Southern processors shy away from bos Indicus cattle and according to Meat Standards Australia (MSA) the presence of tropical breeds have a negative impact on the eating quality of many cuts," Mr McCormick said.

"Although I must add that while processors remain hesitant about tropical breeds, many cuts from tropical bred cattle can still grade MSA 3, 4 or 5.

"Good management is the key here and as with all grades, producing heavier but younger animals will result in improved grading results and combat the tropical content."

He said there was also an opportunity to slightly alter management practices and limit the use of bos Indicus breeds in terminal situations in order to meet the southern market specifications.

"A change in attitude towards risk management and towards change is needed in the WA beef cattle industry," Mr McCormick said.

Mr McCormick said that the second stage of a pre-feasibility study into a northern WA abattoir had been released, with findings outlining the need for a whole-of-supply chain approach.

"It is no use if we just build an abattoir in Broome as supply will be a limiting factor due to the dominance of live export," Mr McCormick said.

"We would have to develop a co-ordinated plan to build a feed-on sector to support the abattoir which can only come about through land tenure reform, tapping and sourcing new groundwater resources and an increased use of irrigation for fodder production.

Date: Newest first | Oldest first


Bushfire Blonde
30/11/2011 7:02:32 AM, on Farm Weekly

And so the fact that the Indonesians cannot afford to buy our boxed beef because of our high processing costs is finally being realised by the Powers That Be! Hurrah! Why hasn't the MLA been pushing this fact? I endeavoured to to push itthrough our ABC but they did not want to know. It it had been wel known,It would have made quite a difference to the debate at the time. There are no Meatworks in Northern Australia close to Asia not only because they cannot afford to buy our boxed beef but also a lot of them have not got any fridges or even 240V power to run them!
pauli T
2/12/2011 5:34:51 PM, on Farm Weekly

Well how about instead of sending 100's of millions of $$$$$ in aid every year we set these countries up so they can accept chilled meat...also the MLA make Millions of $$$$ in profits each year, it's about time they spent some on animal welfare & employ people that have a bit of compassion, not red neck sadists that enjoy being cruel to animals. No need for animal cruelty in any job....


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who