'Golden' opportunity or Trojan Horse?

18 Nov, 2014 01:00 AM
No other environmental issue is based on nothing, in the way of evidence, of any kind of harm

ECOLOGIST Patrick Moore doesn’t talk about the value of genetically modified (GM) crops per se, preferring to focus on campaigning for the immediate introduction of one key GM variety – the vitamin A enhanced Golden Rice – for its potential humanitarian benefits.

Greenpeace co-founder Dr Moore - bitterly estranged from the group for decades - and his brother Michael Moore, with their wives and five children, have established the non-profit Allow Golden Rice Society to counter Greenpeace’s blocking of the product’s market approval.

“No one was campaigning for Golden Rice before we came along,” the Canadian campaigner told Fairfax Agricultural Media on his recent tour of Australia.

“Scientists were talking about it, but no one was demonstrating in front of a Greenpeace office saying ‘you’re guilty of a crime against humanity because eight million children have died because of your opposition to Golden Rice’.

'A crime against humanity'

Dr Moore said other organisations which denounce Golden Rice, by claiming it negatively impacts human health and the environment, were also “guilty of a crime against humanity”.

If Golden Rice provided a cure for Ebola or malaria rather than vitamin A deficiency, it would have been approved almost immediately, he said. Instead, the crop’s development has been held up for 15 years and is continuing to suffer delays because “apparently” it doesn’t generate sufficient yields.

“They’re afraid to let it out now, if it can’t compete with commercial crops, but why don’t they subsidise it then?” he said.

“Right now they’re spending $1 per pill for vitamin A pills to be distributed to millions of people. UNICEF is spending nearly $1 billion a year on vitamin A tablets and still more than one million kids are dying every year.

“But with bio-fortification the nutrient is already in the food, right off the farm. With normal fortification, adding vitamin A to milk or adding iodine to salt, it has to go through a factory for that to happen,” he said.

“Vitamin A deficiency kills more children than malaria, AIDS or tuberculosis. It’s the biggest killer of children in the whole world - and yet we’ve got a cure for it and it’s not allowed to be used.

“If we had a cure for Ebola it’d be used tomorrow morning… even with any side effects, it would still be better than dying.

“Ebola has killed less than 5000 people but vitamin A deficiency kills 6000 children a day, so how could anybody argue with Golden Rice?” he said.

Greenpeace claims Golden Rice is not a sustainable cure for vitamin A deficiency because it encourages over-reliance on a rice-based diet.

They also claim Golden Rice is being used as a 'Trojan Horse' by GM proponents to soften public opinion on the technology.

But Dr Moore said Greenpeace’s campaign to block Golden Rice is form of insanity, “because dead children by the millions are piling up on account of what they’ve done”.

“Greenpeace says Golden Rice may have unknown health and environmental effects and they scare politicians and regulators and everybody with this stuff,” he said.

“That means the people who are trying to bring it forward must get every 't' crossed and every 'i' dotted just perfectly, because if they get stalled in the regulatory process, they get stalled forever.

“That’s just like that AquaBounty salmon that grows twice as fast as normal salmon which the bad guys call ‘Franken-fish’.”

GM crops not designed for harm

Dr Moore said the Allow Golden Rice Society had now reached 35 million people by spreading a positive message through the media.

He claimed the society had also “completely changed the media’s tone on the issue of Golden Rice”, with its Canadian members also touring Europe to campaign.

Dr Moore said environmental concerns about GM technology were misguided, and “no other environmental issue is based on nothing, in the way of evidence, of any kind of harm”.

“The only GM work that’s being done is to improve things,” he said.

“It’s not being done to make things worse or to harm something; it’s being done to improve the crop.”

Dr Moore said one of the reasons his campaign was “so powerful” was the specific focus on Golden Rice.

“We’re not trying to convince everybody about the whole GM thing. We’re not into (GM) labelling and we don’t even care about it, because no one’s going to care if Golden Rice is labelled or not.”

One of the catch-22s in the GM situation, he said, was that the seed company’s customer was not the consumer buying the food in the store.

“Their customer is the farmer, and so it was logical for them to do improvements that were beneficial to the growing of the crop. But now that they’ve got on their feet and profits are coming in from Bt and Roundup Ready GM varieties, they should be getting something on the market that is clearly aimed at consumer benefits,” he said.

“And my number one example of that is Golden Rice, which is now a humanitarian project.”

Dr Moore said fallout from Greenpeace’s destruction of GM wheat research field trials at CSIRO in Canberra in 2011 triggered a change in the activist group's tactics.

It now recruits “urban politicos” to conduct acts of civil disobedience against GM crops, such as the Golden Rice protests in the Philippines, rather than attach the brand to destructive acts.

Asked what it would take for Greenpeace to acknowledge the science and potential humanitarian benefits of Golden Rice, Dr Moore said: “They never will”.

“How could you not agree with Golden Rice?” he said.

Colin Bettles

Colin Bettles

is the national political writer for Fairfax Agricultural Media
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


18/11/2014 6:02:18 AM

As once before in this blog I quote the late Charles Perkins. "Throw a match into dry grass and see how long it is before (the same old, my addition) snakes stick their heads up. The same group of anti GM ers will be out in force with this article justifying the unjustifiable "crime against humanity".
18/11/2014 6:41:46 AM

There is not a shred of evidence that golden rice (GR) can treat, prevent or cure any medical condition, AND it’s the wrong variety altogether. There are two varieties of rice typically grown in Southeast Asia: Japonica, a dryland rice, and Indica grown in wet rice paddies. GR refuses to grow in the wet regions where children are most impacted by vitamin A deficiency. GR contains beta-carotene not vitamin A. There is no evidence that the artificially-inserted beta-carotene even survives storage or cooking. Once again a total sham by GM proponents. Carrots would be a far better option
18/11/2014 8:37:27 AM

ggwagga- beta-carotene is vitamin A. There is no evidence because people like you stop essential research. Any bio-fortified food must be tested. Im sick of the anti-gmo pundits from rich western countries preventing those who really need this technology from accessing it. Shame on you for not supporting.
18/11/2014 9:15:39 AM

Brilliant ggwagga!. Pity those kids and their farmer parents have been too silly to think about planting carrots themselves. And those scientists who have spent all that time putting the genes together to get golden rice. And you've probably solved the peoples' protein shortage as well. They can eat all the rabbits lured by the carrots. I can see your name landing soon on the desk of the Nobel Peace Prize committee already.
18/11/2014 9:31:36 AM

The problem as I see it, is that each GM product is different and needs to be treated differently. Some may well be great for mankind--others potentially fatal . VERY expensive exercise sorting it out. Testing should be performed by an INDEPENDENT umpire.
Bob Phelps
18/11/2014 10:45:05 AM

Moore's claims are a scandalous hoax and his credibility is zero. Vitamin A rice is not deployed as it is a tech dud that would trap starving people in low value staple diets. Moore's numbers are just plain wrong: e.g. he claims each Vitamin A pill costs $1 but the global Micronutrient Initiative reports: "One high-strength vitamin A capsule every six months can help protect a child from the death & disease associated with vitamin A deficiency. These capsules cost approximately two cents each ..." http://www.micronutrient.org/engl ish/View.asp?x=57
18/11/2014 11:15:59 AM

MBM, beta-carotene is a precursor that the human body transforms into vitamin A. MBM you’re obviously so blinded by the GM BS that you are prepared to ignore the facts – GM / Golden Rice is dead in the water because it does not provide realistic answers for those in need. Mega millions has been wasted and false hope given out on this dud; yet another failed GM white elephant. GR claims are actually "drug claims" unless golden rice is tested and approved as a drug for preventing blindness and death, it cannot be sold or marketed with such claims.
18/11/2014 6:49:22 PM

mug is not a mug. We need to develop our independence when considering food safety. Issues such as max residue limits need to be researched by australian scientists, with no financial ties to the corporate world. We cant just accept overseas standards, often the research is conducted by the chemical companies responsible for its supply, conflict of interest? there are many sad stories of farmers in India driven to despair at the cost of their GM seeds, we need to look at the many sides to this complex issue, not just the supposed benefits.
19/11/2014 6:30:06 AM

Yep, as I predicted, same old heads popped up from the smoky grass including mine I guess. Well I'm leaving this circus for good cos I can't stand the lies, lies and more lies from the bloggers. It's not ignorance, it's not lack of knowledge, it's not foolishness that infects these comments but out and out lies from professional and un-redeemable contrarians and fundamentalists. "Good night and good luck"
19/11/2014 11:06:13 AM

Yes Jeffito, you are so right. The lies, deceit and the stench of corruption that surrounds GM and its fabricated, unsubstantiated advantages is mind boggling. The GR is typical of the mischievous deception aided by your smokey grass and warped mirrors. Remember how we were told GM would provide advantages to farmers? I guess these are still in the pipeline as there would appear to only be an advantage to the bottom line of those selling this failed technology. That is unless you consider chemical resistant weeds and pests, and massive increases in chemical usage is a forward step.
1 | 2  |  next >


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who