Australians 'actively avoiding gluten'

08 Jul, 2015 08:12 AM
Comments
11
 
Maybe we should stop asking what's wrong with wheat, and begin asking what's wrong with us

MORE than 10 per cent of Australians actively avoid gluten, according to the CSIRO.

Gluten, a protein found in wheat, barley and rye, arrived with the advent of agriculture 12,000-odd years ago. Considering the first humans are about 2.8 million years old, it is a comparably new addition to our diet.

One common argument against gluten is that we have not had time adapt to this dietary change – some say it takes about 40,000 years.

Exposure to gluten then, irritates our intestines and leads to general lethargy and bloating, an intolerance or coeliac disease.

This is how the saying goes.

"Most of these assertions, however, are contradicted by significant evidence, and distract us from our actual problem: an immune system that has become overly sensitive," counters science writer and author Moises Velasquez-Manoff in a new feature in The New York Times.

As far as the adaptation argument goes, population growth is making genetic change occur at a faster rate. About 100 times faster.

"We are more different genetically from people living 5000 years ago than they were different from Neanderthals," anthropologist John Hawks has said.

This is apparent in the way we have developed a tolerance for dairy within 7000 years.

"Usually, the gene encoding an enzyme named lactase – which breaks down lactose sugars in milk – shuts down after infancy; when dairy became prevalent, many people evolved a mutation that kept the gene turned on throughout life," explains an article in Scientific American.

It stands to reason that, if most of us have adapted to dairy, we should also have adapted to wheat.

"If eating wheat was so bad for us, it's hard to imagine that populations that ate it would have tolerated it for 10,000 years," Sarah A. Tishkoff, a geneticist at the University of Pennsylvania who studies lactase persistence, told The New York Times.

Arguments about whether the "gluten" problems come from eating more gluten or whether gluten-free diets are intrinsically better also lack substance.

Gluten content has also not necessarily increased in wheat in the past 50 years, according to one analysis.

Our wheat consumption has fluctuated, but we are eating about 30 per cent fewer grains than four years ago.

"People buy gluten free biscuits thinking they are healthier – and probably then eat more of them 'guilt free' as they think they are a healthier treat," says dietitian Joanna McMillan.

"When people tell me they have lost weight after giving up gluten I understand why – they are not eating a whole load of energy-dense discretionary foods like cakes, biscuits, doughnuts, croissants and so on. Were they simply to choose gluten-free versions they wouldn't lose weight at all."

Weight-aside, the gluten-free alternatives are not necessarily healthier either, McMillan says.

"Many gluten free products have a higher GI as they are based on potato and rice flour – so unless you really require gluten free (and coeliacs need a strict gluten-free diet) these products are not as healthy as the wholegrain varieties."

And while it is assumed gluten is the problem in the first place, various studies have found this is not always the case.

About 80 per cent of people who avoid gluten (not including those with coeliac disease, which is about 1-2 per cent of the population), do so because of bowel pain, bloating or irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), explains Dr Jane Muir of Monash University.

"A study we published in 2013 we looked at this in more detail in a well designed study (randomised, placebo-controlled, cross-over rechallenge study) – we found no evidence that gluten induced the symptoms in people who believed that they were 'gluten intolerant' and who did not have coeliac disease," Muir says.

Rather they found that a short-chain carbohydrate called Fodmaps, which are also found in non-gluten food like onions and garlic, were causing the symptoms.

All of this isn't to say that coeliac disease – where the immune system reacts abnormally to gluten – and even gluten-sensitivity aren't on the rise.

It seems they are. But so are other allergies, intolerances and immune-related disorders.

"Perhaps the sugary, greasy Western diet – increasingly recognised as pro-inflammatory – is partly responsible," argues Velasquez-Manoff.

"Maybe shifts in our intestinal microbial communities, driven by antibiotics and hygiene, have contributed. Whatever the eventual answer, just-so stories about what we evolved eating, and what that means, blind us to this bigger, and really much more worrisome, problem: The modern immune system appears to have gone on the fritz.

"Maybe we should stop asking what's wrong with wheat, and begin asking what's wrong with us."

Page:
1
SMH
Date: Newest first | Oldest first

READER COMMENTS

VivKay
8/07/2015 8:34:11 AM

Gluten free products are being sold as "health" foods and people are assuming that gluten then must be "bad" or unhealthy! It's only unhealthy for those who are intolerant to gluten and that's a small minority. Most people can consume gluten, and it's a natural protein found in wheat! Nothing normally dangerous at all.
Nikki-2
8/07/2015 1:58:39 PM

So glad to be part of a generation when no one had ever heard of gluten free, when food did not need a scientific analysis before being consumed & we had no need to decipher what came from where. There was one variety of milk and it was called just 'milk', funny, bread was just bread too. How did we ever survive on this plain food ...
Craniologist
9/07/2015 2:27:51 AM

Nikki 2, And now we have moronic manufacturers who make no sense in claiming their product is gluten free in an attempt to cash in on the irrational "gluten free is good" propaganda. I have seen "Gluten Free" and "Naturally Gluten Free" on milk, beef, lamb, jam, salsa and a whole host of other manufactured foods that don't have any grain based products in them at all. Often the Gluten Free label is on a product full of fats and/or sugar, foods that are not healthy at all if they take up a large proportion of your diet. The whole scene would be laughable if it weren't so deceptive.
jeffito
9/07/2015 9:59:53 AM

Reminds me of the great story about the New York bakery window. A pile of tasty looking baked products with the sign "Gluten Free" Next to them an amorphous pile of stuff with a sign "Free Gluten"
Qlander
9/07/2015 10:46:53 AM

In the 70s I 'actively avoided' getting my hair cut - Fashions come, and fashions go.
Comrade Munro
9/07/2015 12:42:14 PM

This is all a result of the demise of the AWB single desk.
Nikki-2
9/07/2015 1:48:16 PM

Companies and marketing making money and lots of it,
Dan-DS
10/07/2015 1:43:12 PM

Last page says it all!
Jude
11/07/2015 4:19:04 AM

This article misses the whole point which is that many people are now allergic to wheat and milk. Why? If you are allergic to gluten you would know it isn't a fad or a fashion, it is a very uncomfortable allergy. Is the wheat we use today different to the wheat used 100 years ago? Does the wheat contain something that some people cannot tolerate? Is it GM, has it been developed using something that many humans cannot tolerate? The wheat industry should do some research to try to find out why if they wish to save their industry.
Meggsiek
13/07/2015 10:44:28 AM

Jude, only about 1% of the population have Celiac Disease, others may have gluten intolerance, much of which is self diagnosed. Often, their issues relate to FODMAPS which are present in many other foods aside from wheat. The rest are doing it due to the growing misinformation spread by the ‘wellness industry’. The wheat we use today is no different to what was used 100 years ago, aside from having better water use efficiency & increased yields. There are no commercial crops of GM wheat anywhere in the world. The Kansas Wheat Farmers are currently undertaking research into Celiac Safe wheat.
1 | 2  |  next >

POST A COMMENT


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *
 

COMMENTS

light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who