Gun laws a mistake: NRA

13 Jul, 2015 08:17 AM
Comments
19
 
Australian people paid a massive price in liberty

IN AN article entitled Australia: There Will be Blood, the National Rifle Association in the US has launched an attack on Australia's gun laws in the latest edition of its most militant gun rights publication, America's First Freedom.

The article claims there is a "growing consensus" in Australia that the gun buyback and ban on semi-automatic weapons introduced after the Port Arthur massacre in 1996 had failed to make the nation safer.

"The Australian people paid a massive price in liberty. Their reward? At best, an unexamined resolution that things were somehow better now," says the article.

"For those who became victims, or who simply examined the situation with open eyes, it was rather clear that they were not. Gun rights were, for all practical purposes, gone forever."

The article warns that US President Barack Obama might support Australian-style gun reforms.

"This is the gun-control regime that our president applauds for its decisive resolve. It robbed Australians of their right to self-defence and empowered criminals, all without delivering the promised reduction in violent crime," it says.

"Australia's gun confiscation is indeed a lesson to America: It is a sign of what is to come if we hold our rights lightly."

Australia's gun laws – particularly those introduced by the Howard government after the Port Arthur massacre – have become a source of fascination in the US and are regularly raised in the ongoing debate over gun violence there.

The NRA's most recent attack on Australian gun laws appears to have been prompted by Mr Obama's raising of their success in an interview he did with Marc Maron?, a comedian with a popular podcast in the US, after the massacre in South Carolina last month.

Referring to Australia's response to the Port Arthur massacre, Mr Obama told Mr Maron: "It was just so shocking the entire country said, 'Well, we're going to completely change our gun laws', and they did. And it hasn't happened since."

Supporters of gun control often cite Australia's laws as evidence that government restrictions on gun ownership can save lives; those opposing gun restrictions raise the laws as an example of Orwellian big-government over-reach.

As evidence of the consensus that Australia's gun laws have failed, the NRA cites a single article published by the Sydney Morning Herald in 2005.

That story quotes the director of the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research, Don Weatherburn, as saying there was not enough evidence to attribute a fall in crime in the 10 years after the introduction of the gun laws to the new restrictions.

"There has been a drop in firearm-related crime, particularly in homicide, but it began long before the new laws and has continued on afterwards. I don't think anyone really understands why. A lot of people assume that the tougher laws did it, but I would need more specific, convincing evidence," he said at the time, noting that a reduction in the availability of heroin had led to lower usage and, in turn, a drop in armed robberies.

Public health research by Professor Simon Chapman has since found that while the rate of gun-related homicide was reducing by 3 per cent a year before the new laws, the pace of the decrease accelerated to 7 per cent a year afterwards.

The US now has a gun homicide rate 370 times that of Australia's, Mr Chapman writes.

Page:
1
SMH
Date: Newest first | Oldest first

READER COMMENTS

THE FARMER
13/07/2015 9:18:19 AM

Iam a gun owner & user & enjoy my shooting , but the Americans are nutters .They all think they are John Wayne - Dirty Harry or gangsta .
Jacky
13/07/2015 10:03:46 AM

But tell me again Mr NRA Man, what did the little kids at Sandy Hook die for?
Invey
13/07/2015 10:10:51 AM

Gun crime in Australia has increased in the last ten years! The criminals still have guns and are freely using them but law abiding citizens are now treated like criminals. Farmers cannot even purchase firearms suitable to control feral pests that are eating our native animals and livestock. You cannot compare the US to AU. There are other nations with as many firearms as the US per capita but have nearly no gun crime.
Qlander
13/07/2015 11:16:00 AM

THE FARMER; I agree I have no problem access the guns I need. The issue in the US is mainly cultural. No civilian has a genuine need for self - loading rifles, these are military weapons.
Doug
13/07/2015 11:41:56 AM

This is NOT about Gun crime IT is about seemingly normal people going off their head and going on a killing spree and NOT being able to get their hands on Military style assault weapons. I have guns, But I cant understand how this gun A110 could have a Cat A fire arm classification.
PayAttention
13/07/2015 1:00:31 PM

Funny. The bikies in Sydney don't seem to care what the law says about many things. Why would they be any different on guns? Time to ban kitchen knives I think. They're dangerous, of course.
Pete
13/07/2015 1:26:22 PM

There is a big difference between owners of firearms in Australia and the USA. Australians Own firearms for sport shooting, Hunting, and as an important tool on properties for feral pest, and lame stock management. Americans owns firearms to defend themselves. It is illegal to use a firearm for self defence in Australia (unless you are a police officer) As regardless of who it is you would be shooting at, Murder is still a crime!
PayAttention
13/07/2015 3:00:44 PM

You must live in town Pete. It can take a long time for "help" to arrive if you're outside of town. Self Defense should never be considered a crime.
Pete
13/07/2015 3:51:18 PM

Pay attention, I have a sheep station on the West Coast of SA, I have 7 rifles and 3 shotguns, I don't make the Laws Mate, if you want to test it out, try shooting someone you catch rustling from you and see what sentence the Judge gives you.
T Rex
13/07/2015 4:00:17 PM

Spot on PayAttention.
1 | 2  |  next >

POST A COMMENT


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *
 

COMMENTS

light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who