Mandatory reporting 'excessive': Joyce

30 Aug, 2014 02:00 AM
Agriculture Minister Barnaby Joyce.
I don’t want ... every jackaroo or jillaroo having to become some sort of legal arbiter
Agriculture Minister Barnaby Joyce.

AGRICULTURE Minister Barnaby Joyce is cautious about the potential for the RSPCA’s mandatory reporting proposal to create an excessive legal requirement on people who work with livestock.

Last week the RSPCA called people who by virtue of their roles are expected to understand animal welfare legislation to be legally required to report animal cruelty.

“All the places I walk on or work on have an internal management mechanism which says you can’t treat animals like that and you will treat them in the appropriate way,” Mr Joyce said.

“I don’t want to have every ringer or every property owner or every jackaroo or jillaroo having to become some sort of legal arbiter about whether an action is legal or not.

“I think we have to give some latitude to self-monitoring… (but) if someone does something that’s obviously beyond the pale, then that’s an issue.”

Mandatory reporting would help create a culture where people are aware of their responsibilities to protect animals, and animal abuse or neglect isn’t tolerated, the RSPCA said. The proposed changes would also include whistleblower protections for those reporting cruelty.

RSPCA Australia chief executive officer Heather Neil said sadly the fate of the animals involved seemed to be lost in the current debate on farm trespass and animal activism.

Australian Pork Limited CEO Andrew Spencer said there was little wrong with the basic principle behind the RSPCA’s proposal.

“If cruelty occurs and you see it, you have a moral obligation to report it and do something about it,” he said.

“What the RSPCA is asking for is to convert that moral obligation into a legal one.

“I don’t see much wrong with that principle so long as it applies to the situations where it’s meant to apply and not just to farm managers.

“Anyone who comes across animal cruelty - including activists on farms who take videos - if they believe they’ve filmed or witnessed animal cruelty, they need to report it as soon as is practical.

“I don’t think there’s ever an excuse for allowing animal cruelty to persist and continue.”

National Farmers Federation president Brent Finlay said pursuing “the highest animal welfare standards possible” was best practice and served the livestock industry’s interests.

But he said the RSPCA’s proposal for a mandatory reporting regime for animal cruelty was problematic as it could add more legislation for an industry already weighed down by costly red tape.

He said individual States had legislative responsibility for animal welfare and the introduction of uniform laws would prove more effective.

Mr Finlay said the farm raid laws proposed by Western Australian Liberal senator Chris Back were designed to protect against biosecurity risks from trespass by animal rights activists.

He said Australia’s strong biosecurity regime provided a marketing advantage in export markets and needed better protection.

Ms Neil said the changes would require increased government support to ensure all agencies in charge of implementing animal welfare regulation are adequately resourced to enable them to respond to the increased number of cruelty reports.

“The RSPCA believes that anyone witnessing animal cruelty has a moral obligation to report it to the relevant authorities,” Ms Neil said.

“But there are some people who, by the nature of their role, are expected to know what animal cruelty is and when action should be taken. These people should have a legal obligation to report cruelty when they see it.”

Colin Bettles

Colin Bettles

is the national political writer for Fairfax Agricultural Media
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


30/08/2014 8:17:02 AM

Recently we had a visit from the RSPCA demanding an inspection of one of our horses, claiming neglect. On inspection he stated that the animal's condition and muscle tone was very good considering it recently had surgery. I reqested a report on the animals condition and information about who made the complaint as it was obviously frivolous, that someone was using the RSPCA for harrassment. It has taken more than 2 months of phone calls to obtain this report, which stated the RSPCA does not have to report on "Freedom of lmformation" on complaints?
Kathleen of Chelsea
1/09/2014 11:44:39 AM

Don't shoot the messenger Barnaby Joyce for without the brave efforts of these activists documenting the cruelty to our farm animals the public would be none the wiser but maybe that's what you want Mr Joyce
1/09/2014 2:47:33 PM

I'm all for it - let's bog the police and courts to the eye balls in this crap.
Bushie Bill
2/09/2014 6:30:36 AM

Oh dear, you do seem to be getting very bolshie of late , Qman. Are the dogs keeping you awake at night?


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who