Live export ban will have ramifications

05 Jul, 2018 04:00 AM

MANY farmers around Western Australia are in a state of doubt with the current situation and unstable nature of the live sheep trade.

Western Australia is unique – 85 per cent of Australian sheep that are live exported are from WA.

We dominate the trade nationally.

A ban on the trade will be detrimental to our growers at farm level and will have a knock-on effect to other industries that support the trade.

Shearers, feedlots, backgrounding facilities and transport and haulage companies – many of which are family owned and operated – will feel the pinch as much as any farmer.

All of these service providers and many other businesses make up the communities will be left to deal with economic damage done to those who rely on income from sheep producers and the wider farming community.

WA is first and foremost an export State – it’s what we do best – we export commodities around the world, whether that is grains, vegetables, hay, wool, iron ore, lithium, gold, truffles or processed meat and live animals.

Global markets depend on WA for food security and we have been providing a steady sheep and cattle supply chain to our international markets for more than 60 years.

Two thirds of WA’s sheep meat is already processed domestically and a percentage of this product would be going into Middle Eastern markets.

While these customers will take processed meat, they also require live animals.

This is an example of Australia’s trusted and reliable reputation of meeting the individual needs of our export customers.

Exporters need our support and input to reliably continue sheep export activities throughout the year.

Consistency of supply will lead to consistency of purchase.

The foundation of global trading is built on successful business relationships.

Any disruption to market availability has an immediate impact on supply chains and threatens Australia’s reputation as a reliable food source.

If disruptions are evident, customers will shop elsewhere.

As a result, I would expect cross-commodity consequences with trading partners losing confidence in Australia’s ability as a primary food supplier.

Livestock Shipping Services recently announced a halt of its live sheep export operations over the northern summer months – add to this the suspension of the export licence issued to Emanuel Exports and a less than ideal start to the winter growing season for pastures and crops, and there will be hundreds of thousands of sheep stranded on farms in WA.

Farmers will increasingly find themselves under pressure to find and pay for feed and will be mindful of the welfare of animals in the paddock.

This could have been avoided if shipping had been able to continue as planned.

We would prefer the trade to continue with all advancement of animal welfare being considered.

The McCarthy Review has made recommendations that I believe, coupled with continued research and adoption, will see animal welfare risks minimised and the trade continued.

Many people ask why Australia needs a live sheep trade and why our animals cannot be processed domestically.

Australian consumers simply do not eat older sheep and offal.

Chilled boxed meat is not a viable option to many export markets due to cultural and religious preference.

Without new, establishing markets to take up these products, animal wastage will be significant and the economic loss will cripple our industry at a producer level.

Live export is a controversial and emotive topic, but it needs to be discussed in its entirety.

The majority of people outside of the agricultural industry do not fully understand the ramifications of a total ban on Australia’s live sheep trade.

The livelihoods of our producers, supporting businesses and local communities who are solely dependent on farming for economic stability will be most significantly impacted.

There is a widening disconnect between agriculture and the broader Australian society.

The opinions of those who support a total ban of the trade, purely on the premise of animal welfare, need to understand that there is much more at stake.

To highlight the importance of the live sheep trade to the wider population, beyond the agricultural community, WAFarmers with Sheep Producers Australia and the National Farmers Federation have launched a website purely for sharing the facts behind Australia’s livestock export industry.

It is every farmer’s responsibility to be promoting the industry and highlighting the important work we do to provide Australian and international consumers with high quality food.

I urge you all to share this website with your networks and educate the whole community about the live sheep trade –

For those who wish to help protect the industry we welcome your help by donations to the combined Industry Fighting Fund enabling a measured and balanced view to be shared with all at

single page
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


5/07/2018 9:46:42 AM, on Farm Weekly

Ample time for appropriate measures to ensure animals were transported in a humane manner. Exporters did not endeavour to make the necessary improvements. Happy to make money off the sheep's back with no thought to the many thousands of sheep who suffered intolerable conditions. Caught out Exports cry foul .... no excuses accepted. The majority of Australians are disgusted with the exporters & the Federal & State Governments lack of action. Exporters have proved they cannot be trusted... Time to END Live Animal Exports.
Christine Osborne
5/07/2018 10:13:33 AM, on Farm Weekly

It is time for WA farmers to cease referring to sheep (or cattle) as "commodities." They are sentient creatures who should not be forced to suffer in Australia's live export trade. The way forward is to invest in on-shore kill/chill as 90% Australian people demand a total ban on the live animal trade for reasons well known to all involved. Thank you.
Katrina Love
5/07/2018 1:06:37 PM, on Farm Weekly

See... here's a tip: "commodities" - live animals aren't commodities, any more than live humans are commodities. Whilst they can certainly BE shipped more humanely than we have seen is the norm for Emanuel Exports, there is NO guarantee, particularly when shipping sheep to the Middle East, that other heat events (a KNOWN risk of northern hemisphere summer trade despite the fact that industry refers to them as "unexpected") will not occur, subjecting thousands of sheep to horrific death by heat stress and tens of thousands to needless suffering. Iron ore is a commodity. Ship iron ore.
5/07/2018 4:43:10 PM, on Farm Weekly

Live Exporters are at the hub of the farmers' dilemma. Their blatant cruelty and neglect of the animals farmers trust to them is the reason public opinion is so much against live exports. No need to remind everyone that their neglect,disregard for animal welfare,and blatant grab for as much profit as possible,going back not months but decades,is the reason why myself and millions of the population want this industry closed and closed permanently. One cannot put profit ahead of animal welfare both here and in the Middle East. My advice,is to diversify seek government assistance and the best of luck
Jerome Drew
6/07/2018 8:15:49 AM, on Farm Weekly

Most of us can see that it is obvious that the current changes will have a huge impact. LSS should be stepping up not backing out. Imagine the impact of a complete Live Export Ban as proposed by ALP - disaster.
13/07/2018 9:00:47 PM, on Farm Weekly

My goodness. Sheep won't have to be fed,,transported or shorn any more and all those people will have to find other jobs? Who knew? As for referring to animals as 'wastage', and 'commodities' that tells u everything we need to know about this writer. And let's not forget, it wasn't that long ago that he was breaking his neck to get as many sheep as he could onto the AWASSI EXPRESS. That's a measure of how concern for welfare. Just the sort of commentary I'd expect from him, greedy parasite, making his living out of animal torture,
Cattle Advocate
2/08/2018 9:32:26 PM, on Farm Weekly

Could people in the world who are heavily reliant on other countries for their food security have trouble trusting BLE after seeing its behaviour in the 2011 LE ban that devastated our TE cattle, BLE with its alternative scheme from, the Land that never was? Should BLE try trading places with these vulnerable people and walk a mile in their shoes how many in BLE went to bed hungry last night?


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
I'm one of the people who want marijuana to be legalized, some city have been approved it but
light grey arrow
#blueysmegacarshowandcruise2019 10 years on Daniels Ute will be apart of another massive cause.
light grey arrow
Australia's live animal trade is nothing but a blood stained industry that suits those who