DAWR investigates live export voyage

12 Jun, 2018 04:00 AM
 Livestock shipping vessel the Awassi Express in Fremantle Port in April 2018.
Livestock shipping vessel the Awassi Express in Fremantle Port in April 2018.

EMANUEL Exports has confirmed it is one of a “number of entities” the Federal Department of Agriculture and Water Resources (DWAR) is investigating over alleged criminal activity in the live export trade.

The investigation was triggered after footage onboard the live export vessel Awassi Express in August 2017 was shown on 60 Minutes in April, shocking the nation.

The images showed sheep dying from severe heat stress and in filthy conditions, while the vessel was on its way to the Middle East.

In a statement issued on Friday, a government spokesperson said the criminal investigation would seek to determine if there had been breaches of the Meat and Livestock Industry Act, the Export Control Act or the Criminal Code Act as it applies to the Australian Meat and Livestock Industry Act and the Export Control Act.

“This includes investigating allegations of overstocking of the vessel, failing to have sufficient food and water available, injury and illness not being treated and accredited veterinarians and stockmen leaving the vessel prior to completion of unloading,” said a department spokesperson.

The department declined to name any individuals or companies involved in the fresh investigation, saying “a range of witnesses are being questioned and information is being examined by the department”.

“While the department is looking at a range of activities that involve a number of entities, it is not appropriate for the department to provide additional information on the status of these actions, or to comment on individuals or companies,” the spokesperson said.

Emanuel Exports managing director Graham Daws confirmed the company was issued with a show cause notice and was part of the investigation.

Mr Daws said the company had been “complying with the requirements of the DAWR since early May when a show cause was first issued”.

“The company is taking all of the allegations on this matter very seriously,” Mr Daws said.

“Whilst cleared of any wrongdoing by the Department of Agriculture in its initial investigation, we are assessing the video footage in an effort to clarify a number of the allegations, as well as investigating the possible inadequacies of the vessel and its management at the time.

“The footage does not in any way represent a normal voyage to the Middle East and we are determined to find more answers to why the voyage ultimately ended the way it did and to be able to use these findings for preventing any similar occurrences into the future.

“The company has a very good record in delivering sheep cargoes to the Middle East, the fact that its delivery success rates exceed the industry average is just one of them.

“Just because we are the largest sheep exporter from Australia doesn’t mean we pay any less heed to the way we conduct the business – in fact it makes us work harder to do it better and deliver higher levels of sustainable animal welfare outcomes.”

Farm Weekly understands that Emanuel’s lawyers had made submissions to DAWR on why it should be allowed to continue to export.

Emanuel Exports has been embroiled in major controversy after the Awassi Express incident last year which saw 2400 sheep, or 3.76 per cent of 63,804 sheep on board, die when it was caught in a heat wave during the 23 day voyage from Fremantle to Kuwait, the United Arab Emirates and Qatar.

A whistleblower on the vessel later supplied footage from five voyages to Animals Australia before it was aired on 60 Minutes, which coincided with the arrival of the Awassi Express in Fremantle to undergo another voyage in April.

This later voyage reportedly left Fremantle after a lengthy delay without any sheep on board.

Emanuel Exports is by far the largest exporter of sheep from Australia, reportedly sending 1,228,506 head of sheep in 2017 to its customers in the Middle East.

Although there were two other incidents involving Emanuel Exports last year where the mortality rate was above 1pc, the mortality rate during that 12 month period totalled 0.76pc.

To show Emanuel’s contribution to the live sheep trade there were 1,864,770 head of sheep exported from Australia between April 2017 and April 2018, with 1,537,034 departing from Fremantle.

Despite the misinformation in the public domain about the live sheep trade Meat and Livestock Australia’s (MLA) website is clear that “over 99pc of all Australian animals arrive fit and healthy at their destinations”.

“In addition to providing much needed protein for global communities, the livestock export industry also supports the livelihoods of thousand of farming families and communities,” MLA said.

“The industry employs 13,000 people across rural and regional Australia and is worth $1.8 billion to the Australian economy.

“The industry is also vital in underpinning livestock prices for sheep, cattle and goat producers across Australia by providing an additional market for livestock.”

Date: Newest first | Oldest first


12/06/2018 9:27:24 PM, on Farm Weekly

If there is any prosecution at all, it will be swept under the carpet for years until they think we've all forgotten and gone away. Then there might be a slap on the wrist with a wet bus ticket.
sherry stumm
13/06/2018 4:41:29 PM, on Farm Weekly

This is a disgusting, immoral trade in live animals which causes them untold suffering because of the conditions on the ships and the fact we are just too far away for this ever to be satisfactory. Stop it now. It has been a hidden trade of horrible suffering. Listen to the people and don't think you can keep this trade going undetected any more.
13/06/2018 7:48:26 PM, on Farm Weekly

The Live Export Industry will receive a warning from the Minister from Agriculture, a real tough guy, and it will be business as usual, until next time. He will forget to mention the the decades of 'isolated incidents' and all the inherent breaches of animal welfare.


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
NO ships with live animals should be leaving Australia. This industry is animal abuse and animal
light grey arrow
we are happy to have Aldi in katanning doing business with WAMCO we also wanted and in great
light grey arrow
This is a disgrace but what can you expect from a Liberal Government that insists on making