Testing informs herbicide choice at Coorow

January 20 2022 - 2:00am
Armed with knowledge about the resistance profile of their weeds, the Birch's are combining some older chemistry with newer, premium herbicides for maximum effect.

BUYING a new property can produce unknown factors which can take time for the new owners to become familiar - including working with the soils, terrain and weeds.

When the Birch family, Catalina Farms, Coorow, purchased a neighbouring property, historic 'Koobabbie', they had reason to expect that herbicide resistance would be less of a problem because there had been limited use of herbicides in its 114 history of farming.



Daniel Birch, who farms with his wife Jen, parents Rod and Shelley and long-term team member Justin Passamani, said the purchase conveniently coincided with the opportunity to be involved with independent herbicide resistance testing in 2020.

"The testing was arranged through the Liebe Group and conducted at the Australian Herbicide Resistance Initiative (AHRI)," Mr Birch said.

"We were keen to test some theories we had about resistance status of weeds on Catalina and also to get some baseline information about Koobabbie to help us plan our herbicide program."

The testing revealed a number of things that surprised the Birchs.

To start with, they found there was Group 2 (B) resistant ryegrass in paddocks on Koobabbie that had no history of Group 2 herbicide use.

"This demonstrated just how easy it is for herbicide resistance to move in seed or hay, or on machinery," Mr Birch said.

"Obviously we can use this information to avoid using chemistry that we know has little to no efficacy on ryegrass."

The other major finding was that Group 12 (F) resistance in wild radish was much higher than we expected across the farm.

This has led the Birchs to include more premium products in their program to target resistant ryegrass and wild radish and drive down the weed seed bank as quickly as possible.

On the flip side, they also discovered that they can save money by using trifluralin at lower rates in seasons with good growing conditions, where there is less need for a long residual effect.

"In those years where the crop gets off to a good start, the crop competition effect kicks in early to suppress weeds," Mr Birch said.

Daniel Birch, Catalina Farms, Coorow, said the take-home message from recent herbicide resistance testing was the power of mode of action mixtures.

By taking on board the resistance testing results from weed seed samples collected across the State, Mr Birch was reassured by the fact that the resistance issues they faced were essentially the same as other growers.

"The big take home message for us was the power of mode of action mixtures," he said.

"From the overall survey results across Australia, the resistance frequency to stand-alone pre-emergence herbicides ranged from 10 to 34 per cent, yet resistance to herbicide mixtures ranged from 0 to 6pc."

The AHRI resistance testing program is led by Roberto Busi.

In 2019, annual ryegrass seed samples from 298 farms were submitted, representing 579 populations from four States in Australia, and these were tested for resistance to 21 herbicides applied at the recommended rate - 12 standalone and nine two-way mixtures.



In total, 15,876 individual resistance tests were conducted to screen two million seeds against registered herbicides and herbicide mixtures at the recommended label rate.

Dr Busi said the mixtures that growers could confidently incorporate in their annual ryegrass program are trifluralin and Sakura mix, Luximax and triallate, and clethodim and butroxydim.

"When applied at full rate for each component, these mixtures can achieve a better outcome than the same herbicides applied as stand-alone treatments against annual ryegrass with known resistance," Dr Busi said.

For wild radish, 200 samples were tested over a period of two years and resistance to Groups 2 (B), 4 (I) and 12 (F) were all more than 50pc resistant.

At 70pc resistant, Group 2 (B) herbicides should probably be dropped from most wild radish herbicide programs and Group 4 (I) is under threat.

"In 2021, we found that mixing Group 12 (F) with Group 6 (C) herbicide bromoxynil vastly improved control of wild radish," Dr Busi said.



"From 51pc resistant to Group 12 (F) down to less than 15pc of samples resistant to the 12 (F) plus 6 (C) mixture."

Dr Busi also said it was important to emphasise that herbicide resistance testing was conducted on small, actively growing weed seedlings in a glasshouse environment.

"In the field, spray failures can easily occur, even in susceptible weed populations, if the herbicide is applied under the wrong conditions or to plants that are too large or stressed," he said.

"This is particularly true for wild radish."

Want weekly news highlights delivered to your inbox? Sign up to the Farm Weekly newsletter.



Get the latest Western Australia news in your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to stay up to date.

We care about the protection of your data. Read our Privacy Policy.